You are one: TheOnlyCritic picks the top 25 movies of 2024
What began as a bleak year for moviegoers, due to the dual writer-and-actor strikes that caused the release pipeline to slowly deplete, turned into a steady rebound just in time for the summer movie season. It was a strange year at the movies—there’s no doubt about that—but it was also strangely and oddly rewarding. We witnessed what was probably the most jaw-dropping body horror film of the last twenty years (if not the century), with Coralie Fargeat's unforgettable mind-melter “The Substance.” We returned to Arrakis in Denis Villeneuve’s blockbuster epic “Dune: Part Two,” and animated films made a ferocious comeback with titles like “The Wild Robot,” “Flow,” and “Memoir of a Snail.”
At the same time, there were major breakouts from indie studios. A24 had its first-ever #1 opening with Alex Garland’s startling and eerily timely “Civil War,” while NEON brought Oz Perkins’ “Longlegs” to theaters, bolstered by the year's most cryptic marketing campaign. Meanwhile, adults returned to theaters to witness the pope’s vape and watch power plays unfold in “Conclave.” While there was no breakout smash like “Barbie” or “Oppenheimer” this year, aside from “Wicked,” this allowed smaller, more intimate, and just plain weird films to thrive in an ecosystem we've been told only caters to major studio blockbusters. There were plenty of surprises this year, and, as is often the case, if anyone tells you “there were no good movies this year,” chances are, they simply didn’t see enough of them.
Without further ado here are my selections for the top 25 movies of the year:
25.REBEL RIDGE
Writer-director Jeremy Saulnier’s Netflix thriller “Rebel Ridge” is the quintessential "dad movie," packed with action but with a deeper, more meaningful layer beneath its intense shoot-outs and high-stakes sequences. The film offers a sharp commentary on rural America, exploring how we treat people and communities in the face of adversity. With its gripping narrative and strong performances from Aaron Pierre and Don Johnson, “Rebel Ridge” stands out as one of the better films in Netflix’s catalog and it’s a thrilling ride that combines both heart and grit. (On Netflix).
24. HOW TO HAVE SEX
In Molly Manning Walker's vital debut “How to Have Sex,” three British teenagers embark on a summer getaway before returning to college—a trip that takes several uncomfortable and thought-provoking turns. The film grapples with important themes of consent, the complexities of teenage friendships, and the pressures that shape young lives. With a compelling soundtrack, stunning cinematography, and a beautifully restrained performance by Mia McKenna-Bruce, “How to Have Sex” is a difficult-to-watch film that deserves to be seen by as wide an audience as possible. This marks one of the standout directorial debuts of the year. (On VOD and streaming on MUBI).
23.IMMACULATE
Sydney Sweeney fully immerses herself in her role as Sister Cecilia in “Immaculate,” a dark, atmospheric nunsploitation film that explores themes of body autonomy and organized religion. Set in a gothic Italian convent, the story follows Cecilia, a nurse who mysteriously becomes pregnant and is caught in a web of supernatural events and horrifying deaths. Sweeney's wild performance (the final scene is bonkers!) and the film's eerie atmosphere keeps viewers engaged and, in the end, “Immaculate,” combines tension, gore, and social commentary, all but cementing Sweeney’s status as a cultural force to be reckoned with. (On Hulu).
22.MEMOIR OF A SNAIL
Adam Elliot's latest animated film, “Memoir of a Snail,” blends whimsical storytelling with deep, thought-provoking themes about life's purpose and resilience. It follows Grace, a lonely hoarder, and her brother Gilbert, as they face challenging circumstances that separate them and shape their lives. Through an eccentric yet emotionally rich narrative, the film explores trauma, self-discovery, and personal growth, with standout performances from the voice cast featuring Sarah Snook and Jacki Weaver. The film's unique combination of humor, heartache, and striking visuals makes it one of the most memorable and impactful films this year. (On VOD).
21.STRANGE DARLING
JT Mollner’s “Strange Darling” is a taut, twisty thriller that thrives on keeping its secrets, with a narrative full of surprises that’s best experienced without knowing too much in advance. The film follows "The Lady" (Willa Fitzgerald), who is pursued by a serial killer known as "The Demon" (Kyle Gallner) through the backwoods, setting up a tense cat-and-mouse game. However, the film quickly subverts expectations, using a non-linear storytelling technique and exploring themes like gender roles in unexpected ways. While the film’s final act loses some of its earlier momentum and falls into more traditional thriller tropes, the strong performances, particularly from Fitzgerald and Gallner, and Mollner’s ambitious direction make “Strange Darling” a wild ride that sticks with you. Special shout-out to actor-turned Cinematographer Giovanni Ribisi (On VOD).
20.A COMPLETE UNKNOWN
Timothée Chalamet disappears into the enigma that is Bob Dylan in James Mangold’s sturdy, down-the-middle biopic “A Complete Unknown.” Mangold has always excelled at making these types of low-stakes dramas as opposed to say, “Indiana Jones” movies and it shows here. Edward Norton is equally as captivating playing the legendary Pete Seeger while Monica Barbaro stuns playing Joan Baez. A great companion piece alongside Mangold’s own “Walk the Line.” (In theaters Christmas Day).
19.WILL & HARPER
"Will & Harper" is a heartfelt road-trip documentary about two long-time friends, Will Ferrell and transgender woman Harper Steele, reconnecting after Steele undergoes a life-changing transition. The film follows their 16-day journey across America, revisiting places that shaped Steele’s identity, while addressing the political and social challenges she faces. Along the way, they encounter moments of humor, discomfort, and genuine connection, highlighting the deep bond between them. The film offers a powerful message of love and acceptance, with the hope that it will inspire greater understanding and bridge divides in a polarized society. (On Netflix).
18.EMILA PÈREZ
"Emilia Pérez" is a unique and captivating film by Jacques Audiard that blends a cartel thriller, musical numbers, and themes of identity and love into one whirlwind package. It follows Rita (Zoe Saldaña in an Oscar worthy performance), a defense lawyer in Mexico City, who becomes involved with a cartel leader seeking gender-affirming surgery, leading to a complex arrangement with their wife, Jessi. Four years later, Rita’s life is turned upside down when Emilia Pérez (Karla Sofía Gascón - flawless) returns, desperate to reconnect with Jessi and her children. Though the film’s tone can be inconsistent and its third act a little muddled, its bold musical sequences and unconventional storytelling leave a resounding impact. (On Netflix).
17.WE LIVE IN TIME
John Crowley’s “We Live In Time” is one of the few films this year that completely dismantled every emotion in my body. The film tugs at the heartstrings in profound ways, thanks to the exceptional chemistry between Andrew Garfield and Florence Pugh, who play a couple navigating turbulent personal challenges. Anyone brave enough to watch should be prepared—keep those tissues close, because this one is a real emotional rollercoaster (On VOD).
16.DÍDI
Very few films have captured the spirit of 2008 as powerfully as Sean Wang’s fiery coming-of-age story “Dídi.” The film follows a young teenager (Izzac Wang) as he navigates the complexities of finding his place in a world shaped by social media. With its sharp, heartfelt storytelling, “Dídi” stands out as another exceptional directorial debut in 2024, offering a fresh and authentic perspective on adolescence and forging your own path forward. (On VOD and Peacock).
15.THE LAST STOP IN YUMA COUNTY
“The Last Stop in Yuma County” is a slick, suspenseful 90-minute film set in a single location, where a group of colorful characters are stranded at a diner in the middle of nowhere. Writer-director Francis Galluppi, set to helm the next “Evil Dead” film, skillfully plays with expectations, steering the plot in one direction before delivering unexpected twists that keep viewers on their toes in another. The movie follows a tense situation involving two bank robbers and a group of unsuspecting strangers, with a standout performance from Jim Cummings as a traveling salesman. Galluppi’s confident direction and creative flourishes make this one an engaging, fun, and unpredictable ride. (on VOD).
14.HIT MAN
Richard Linklater’s “Hit Man” is a sleek, sexy, and wildly fun comedy that lets Glen Powell shine as Gary Johnson, an undercover cop with a knack for disguising himself as a hitman. Co-written by Powell and Linklater, the film, inspired by a true story, follows Johnson as he tricks people—jaded wives, disgruntled employees, angsty teens—into hiring him to off their enemies. The real kicker, though, is the sizzling romance between Powell’s character and Maddy Masters (Adria Arjona), who hires him to kill her abusive husband, sparking some electric chemistry. With breakneck humor and fast-paced twists, Linklater returns to top form, delivering a ride that's as hilarious as it is thrilling. (On Netflix).
13.THE FALL GUY
David Leitch’s “The Fall Guy” is a wildly fun, action-packed tribute to stunt performers, blending outrageous summer movie thrills with a heartfelt homage to the hard work of stuntmen and women. Ryan Gosling stars as Colt Stevens, a legendary stuntman, alongside Emily Blunt with their banter and charm driving the film’s infectious energy. Loosely inspired by the 1980s TV show, the film follows Colt’s return to the industry to track down a missing action star while rekindling a romance with Blunt’s character, all set against thrilling, practical stunts. Through it all, Leitch’s love for stunt work shines through, making “The Fall Guy” an entertaining, old-school romp that celebrates the unsung heroes of the film industry. (On VOD and Peacock).
12.NOSFERATU
Robert Eggers' “Nosferatu” is a spine-chilling reimagining of the 1922 silent classic, masterfully blending gothic horror with Eggers' signature atmospheric tension. Bill Skarsgård delivers a haunting performance as Count Orlok, creating an unsettling presence that lingers well after the film ends, while Lily-Rose Depp shines as Ellen, a woman drawn into Orlok’s terrifying obsession. The film’s production design, sweeping camera work, and eerie sound design immerse viewers alongside a narrative that remains faithful to the original while adding Eggers' unique touch. With stellar performances, including Willem Dafoe’s eccentric turn as Herr Knock, “Nosferatu” is a visually stunning yet deeply unsettling experience. (In theaters Christmas Day).
11.CONCLAVE
Edward Berger's “Conclave” is a gripping papal thriller that delves into the secretive and intense election process following the death of a pope, with powerful performances from Ralph Fiennes and Stanley Tucci. The film explores the political battle among cardinals—liberal and conservative—each vying for power as secrets are uncovered and lies exposed in the Vatican. With a dynamic score by Volker Bertelmann and memorable supporting performances, including Isabella Rossellini and John Lithgow, “Conclave” becomes an enthralling drama that mirrors the existential choices faced in elections. The film’s surprising twists and climactic reveal make it a thought-provoking exploration of faith, power, and the future of the Church. (on VOD and Peacock).
10.SING SING
A deeply moving and impactful exploration of healing and redemption, Greg Kwedar’s “Sing Sing” powerfully delves into the transformative potential of rehabilitation and the search for purpose in the face of overwhelming odds. Inspired by a documentary about the notorious Sing Sing Correctional Facility, the film highlights how theatre was used as a therapeutic outlet to help incarcerated men express themselves and foster personal growth. The result is one of the most emotionally cathartic films of the year, anchored by two exceptional performances: the ever-impressive Colman Domingo and newcomer Clarence Macline, who portrays himself, a former inmate whose journey of self-discovery is both raw and inspiring. (In theaters).
9.LONGLEGS
A dark, twisted thriller that will leave you unsettled, “Longlegs” is one wild ride. Directed by Oz Perkins, this serial killer procedural is a mix of “Se7en” and “Silence of the Lambs,” with Nicolas Cage delivering an unforgettable, creepy performance as the mysterious killer, Longlegs. Makia Monroe shines as the FBI agent chasing him, and Blair Underwood adds a solid supporting turn as her boss. Slow and eerie, the film blends psychological terror with supernatural elements, making it a truly chilling experience. Hail Satan! (On VOD).
8.THE WILD ROBOT
DreamWorks Animation's “The Wild Robot” is an emotional and visually stunning adaptation of Peter Brown’s beloved books, showcasing the studio’s growing ability to compete with Pixar on a major scale. Directed by Chris Sanders, the film tells the story of Rozzum 7134, a robot who awakens on an island and unexpectedly becomes a mother figure to an orphaned gosling named Brightbill. As Roz navigates her new role and learns about family, survival, and self-identity, the film explores themes of parenting and belonging. With a strong voice cast, breathtaking animation, and a heartfelt story, “The Wild Robot” is easily the best animated film of the year. (On VOD).
7.THE BRUTALIST
Brady Corbet's “The Brutalist” is a sweeping, three-and-a-half-hour epic that explores the complexities of the American dream, cementing Corbet's place as a modern-day Stanley Kubrick or Orson Welles. Starring Adrien Brody as Laszlo Toth, a Jewish Hungarian architect, the film follows his journey to America post-WWII, where he becomes entangled with a wealthy tycoon played by Guy Pearce in a career-best role. Shot in stunning VistaVision and 70mm by Lol Crawley, the film is driven by a powerful score and Corbet's meticulous direction. While it may leave some viewers frustrated, “The Brutalist” is a challenging, ambitious cinematic experience that will be admired for years to come. (In theaters December 20th).
6.ANORA
Sean Baker’s “Anora” is a wild, darkly comedic ride that flips the script on the classic “Pretty Woman” trope, with a Gen-Z twist. Mikey Madison shines as Ani, a tough New York sex worker who gets tangled up with a Russian high roller, played by Mark Eydelshteyn, in a chaotic romance full of lies, love, and a whole lot of partying. What starts as a dream marriage soon crashes into a messy, hilarious trainwreck as Ani desperately clings to the hope that her life can still change. With a gut-punch of an ending, Baker delivers a film brimming with humor, heartbreak, and a standout performance by Madison. (In theaters).
5.CHALLENGERS
Luca Guadagnino’s “Challengers” is a sizzling, high-stakes love triangle set in the world of professional tennis, with a propulsive score by Trent Reznor and Atticus Ross that rages with intense, 90s-inspired energy. Zendaya gives the performance of her career as Tashi, a tennis prodigy who masterfully manipulates two rivals—played by Mike Faist and Josh O’Connor—through a whirlwind of desire, competition, and emotional turmoil. Spanning 13 years, the film weaves through their relationships, shifting between the past and present with fluidity and tension, culminating in an electrifying, can't-look-away tennis match. With steamy encounters, captivating performances, and a fierce, sensual energy, “Challengers” is a cinematic gem that keeps you on the edge of your seat. Game. Set. Match. (On Prime Video).
4.HUNDREDS OF BEAVERS
In a world where blockbuster budgets often skyrocket, “Hundreds of Beavers” stands as a testament to creativity and resourcefulness, delivering a wild, irreverent comedy that packs more punch than most high-budget films. This ultra-low-budget slapstick homage to cartoons and silent cinema follows Jean Kayak, a quirky fur trapper, as he embarks on a ludicrous quest to capture hundreds of beavers, all while battling absurd challenges and practical effects mayhem. With its DIY costumes, eccentric performances, and nonstop chaos, the film channels the spirit of “Looney Tunes” and “Tom & Jerry,” proving that a little creativity can go a long way. The film’s third act inside a beaver dam is an explosion of inventive, low-budget wizardry that will leave you in awe and laughing uncontrollably, making it a must-see for fans of unhinged, physical comedy. (On TUBI).
3.CIVIL WAR
Alex Garland’s “Civil War” offers a chilling, apolitical look at a fractured United States on the brink of collapse, seen through the eyes of a group of photojournalists documenting the chaos. With Texas and California seceding to form the “Western Forces” and a fascist administration at the helm, the film explores the devastating effects of a divided country without taking sides. The story unfolds with a raw, documentary-style approach, focusing on moments of tension and survival, while keeping the audience on edge with its harrowing visuals. By the end, “Civil War” leaves a haunting impression of what a fractured nation could look like, amplified by Garland's signature ambiguity. (On MAX).
2.DUNE: PART TWO
Denis Villeneuve’s “Dune: Part Two” surpasses its sleepy predecessor in every way, delivering a stunning, visually rich epic that expands the world of Arrakis with greater pace, higher stakes, and jaw-dropping discoveries. Timothée Chalamet’s Paul Atreides continues his journey towards becoming a messianic leader, while Austin Butler’s menacing Feyd-Rautha stands out as one of the best screen villains in recent memory. The film weaves complex political intrigue and breathtaking action, from sandworm rides to brutal blade fights, while further exploring themes of colonialism and religion. With stellar performances from a star-studded cast, including Zendaya, Florence Pugh, and Christopher Walken, “Part Two” solidifies “Dune” as one of the defining sci-fi franchises of a generation, ranking alongside “The Lord of the Rings” and “Star Wars.” This is as big as blockbusters get! (On MAX).
1.THE SUBSTANCE
Coralie Fargeat's “The Substance” is a grotesque, body horror masterpiece that delivers an unflinching, brutal allegory about the societal pressures women face regarding their appearance. Demi Moore rocks as Elisabeth, a fading actress who undergoes a terrifying transformation through a drug that creates a younger version of herself, played by the brilliant Margaret Qualley. Fargeat masterfully blends visceral body horror with poignant social commentary, using shocking visuals and unsettling close-ups to explore objectification and the desperate desire for validation in the age of social media. With jaw-dropping practical effects, an audacious final act, and a bold, uncompromising vision, “The Substance” is not just the standout horror film of the year—it’s a haunting, unforgettable cinematic experience that’s undeniably the best film of 2024. (on MUBI).
HONORABLE MENTIONS: The next few movies that just missed the cut, but you should still see.
Jim Henson Idea Man
Inside Out 2
Heretic
Monkey Man
Road House
Love Lies Bleeding
TV shows I really enjoyed this year:
Shogun
Welcome to Wrexam
Fallout
Baby Reindeer
Presumed Innocent
The Penguin
RECAP: The Top 25 movies of the year:
The Substance
Dune: Part Two
Civil War
Hundreds of Beavers
Challengers
Anora
The Brutalist
The Wild Robot
Longlegs
Sing Sing
Conclave
Nosferatu
The Fall Guy
Hit Man
The Last Stop in Yuba County
Didi
We Live In Time
Emila Perez
Will & Harper
A Complete Unknown
Strange Darling
Memoir of a Snail
Immaculate
How To Have Sex
Rebel Ridge
See you in 2025!
Comments