'The Spongebob Musical' review: Croswell brings the cartoon to life in jubilant, colorful production
Courtesy of The Croswell Opera House
Few television shows have enjoyed the pop culture longevity of Nickelodeon’s beloved children’s classic “SpongeBob SquarePants.” Ask a group of ten millennials, "Is mayonnaise an instrument?" and I’d bet at least half, if not all of them, would immediately recognize the reference. That kind of enduring cultural impact is what makes “The SpongeBob Musical,” now playing on The Croswell stage, feel tailor-made for longtime fans. With an impressive music catalog featuring songs by Cyndi Lauper, Panic! At the Disco, Aerosmith, John Legend, and others, this feel-good show also has a little something for everyone. It’s not just for kids.
The Croswell has gone all out in transforming its stage into the vibrant, underwater world of Bikini Bottom, home to, among many others, SpongeBob, Sandy Cheeks, and Patrick Star. Under the direction and choreography of Debra Ross Calabrese, the cast has brought these iconic characters to life with an energy and enthusiasm that feels just right.
From the moment the show begins, there’s no doubt that Steven Kiss IS SpongeBob SquarePants—the world's most optimistic fry cook, jellyfishing enthusiast. Alongside him, Matthew Johnston nails the lovable, rock-dwelling starfish Patrick Star, while Sabriyah Davis dutifully captures Sandy Cheeks’ intelligence and resourcefulness. Jeffrey Beam’s Squidward Tentacles, Jeffrey King’s money-hungry Mr. Krabs, Maxwell Lam’s conniving, scene-stealing Plankton, and Meg Clark’s delightfully robotic Karen round out the key ensemble, and each actor perfectly embodies the spirit of their animated counterpart. The vocal performances are equally impressive; if you closed your eyes, you might just think you’re listening to the original voice cast.
The supporting roles are just as strong. Michael Yuen brings infectious and big “breeeeeaaaaking news” energy to the role of Bikini Bottom's news anchor, Perch Perkins, while Hallie Yuen shows off a wide vocal range as Mr. Krabs’ teenage daughter, Pearl (who is, oddly enough, a whale). Erin Yuen plays the Kelp juice-loving Mrs. Puff, and Kylie McElrath is perfectly cast as the SpongeBob-obsessed fanatic Patchy the Pirate. In a fun bit of meta-casting, Angie Heath, the mayor of Adrian, plays the mayor of Bikini Bottom, who’s trying to lead her town through an impending crisis.
With so many characters packed into a nearly three-hour show, it’s impressive how each one gets a moment to shine. The ensemble also plays a vital role, bringing to life fan-favorite characters like Old Man Jenkins, the Flying Dutchman, and Mermaid Man & Barnacle Boy. It’s a blast watching the cast channel the playful, high-energy vibe that fans expect from a “SpongeBob” production.
The stakes are high, as the citizens of Bikini Bottom face an imminent threat: a volcano is about to erupt, threatening to destroy the town. Sandy has a plan to stop it, but Plankton has his own sinister agenda—one that includes a hilarious rap to the Bikini Bottom residents, attempting to convince them that his plan is the superior, more sustainable option. Meanwhile, Squidward is organizing a benefit concert (which, at one point, involves a massive tap-dancing number inspired by “A Chorus Line”), Patrick is being adored by a school of impressionable sardines, and Mr. Krabs is, predictably, trying to profit off the town's impending doom.
While side plots can sometimes feel like filler, “The SpongeBob Musical” makes them work by weaving them seamlessly into the main storyline. All of these threads come together in a rousing finale that had both kids and adults on their feet for the iconic, now generational tune "Best Day Ever." Vocally, under the direction of Aaron Ross, and musically, under the leadership of Ray Novak, this cast delivers an unforgettable performance. The costumes, designed by Abbie Sage Hall, are equally flawless, adding a visual richness to the production.
A special shout-out is deserved for the sound team, led by Karl Kasichke and foley operator Kylie Bushman, whose work brings the world of Bikini Bottom to life—from SpongeBob’s squeaky shoes to Squidward’s tentacle movements. The projections, inspired by the cartoon, complement Leo Babcock’s scenic design, which authentically recreates iconic “SpongeBob” locations like the Krusty Krab, the Chum Bucket, and the homes of Patrick, Squidward, and SpongeBob himself.
At its heart, “The SpongeBob Musical” offers a powerful message about overcoming adversity and staying true to yourself. It’s a show for anyone who has ever felt like an outsider or struggled to feel good enough. SpongeBob isn’t just a sponge with a love for Krabby Patties; he’s the embodiment of relentless optimism in a world that often feels uncertain. His unshakable positivity, paired with the support of his best friends, is a reminder of the importance of joy and resilience. This colorful, heartwarming production is a celebration of those qualities, and with an incredible cast and crew, it delivers a joyous experience from start to finish.
Aye aye, captain!
The Croswell’s production of THE SPONGEBOB MUSICAL continues through Sunday, December 1st. Tickets can be purchased at Croswell.org