'Heretic' TIFF review: Hugh Grant elevates a cautionary tale about religion
Courtesy of A24/TIFF
What do YOU believe? This central question resonates throughout "Heretic," the new psychological horror film from co-writers and directors Scott Beck and Bryan Woods. The film, while probing and far from original in its exploration of the limitations and contradictions of religion, is elevated by a formidable performance from Hugh Grant. His portrayal is so intense that he chews through his dialogue with the fervor of a David Mamet character. Grant enhances an otherwise familiar cat-and-mouse plot with his presence. By the film's end, "Heretic" doesn't offer revelations beyond what skeptics of religion might already know, but watching Grant, clad in thick Dahmer-style glasses and grandpa sweaters as he expounds his theological theories, makes the experience worthwhile.
Grant plays Mr. Reed, a seemingly kind and impressionable old man who is visited by Sister Barnes (Sophie Thatcher) and Sister Paxton (Chloe East – a standout) as they arrive at his home to preach about the Church of Latter-day Saints. What begins as a sweet and innocent interaction quickly turns dark when Mr. Reed engages the sisters in a theological debate centered on the question: "What is the one true religion?"
As the doors are locked and the lights go out, Reed subjects the sisters to a series of mind games to test their faith and convictions. Beck and Woods expertly balance anxiety and tension, using close-ups and exceptional cinematography by Chung-hoon Chung (“Oldboy”) to build suspense. Grant’s performance oscillates between cheerfully silly—at one point, he delivers a memorable impersonation of Jar Jar Binks—and sadistically cruel, keeping the audience on edge with his unpredictable behavior. It’s arguably the darkest role of Grant’s impressive career, showcasing his versatility and his recent career moves.
Grant's portrayal of Mr. Reed also reveals humor, and watching him embrace such a different role is both thrilling and engaging. East and Thatcher rise to the challenge as the two sisters face off against him. East captures the naive innocence of a devout Mormon who has never questioned her beliefs, while Thatcher convincingly portrays her growing doubt. As the movie intensifies, both actresses maintain strong performances, making them a perfect complement to Grant’s performance.
"Heretic" keeps the audience guessing and makes valid points about the state of religion and its interpretations in Western societies. However, for those already well-versed in these debates or firm in their beliefs, the film may not offer much new insight. The story’s less surprising revelations and Reed’s motives lead to a final half-hour that turns into a somewhat campy, provocative ride.
Grade: B
"Heretic" premiered at the Toronto International Film Festival and will be released in theaters by A24 on Friday, November 15th.
